danmarino
Recruit
Posts: 9
Karma: 4
Pilot name: Dan Marino
Platform: Facebook
Clan: Raptor Tactics
League: Champion
Server Region: North America
Favorite robot: Griffen
|
Post by danmarino on Jun 22, 2017 2:13:32 GMT -5
I currently sit at low Diamond (3) or High Gold (1). I can buy with IP either 1 Butch or 2 Docs. Overall which is a better mech? I use a RDB Griff and Trident Carnage for range fighting. I've saved up about 9000 gold and could also but a Fury. I've been hording my gold for the upcoming Dash bots and Scourge.
Bottom line is... Which is more worthwhile? Butch or Doc? And what setup?
From what I can gather it seems that Ork/Tul for Doc and Trebuchet for Butch are really the only options.
Thanks!
|
|
|
Post by ΒΣRΖΣRKΛ²³ on Jun 22, 2017 2:26:56 GMT -5
I currently sit at low Diamond (3) or High Gold (1). I can buy with IP either 1 Butch or 2 Docs. Overall which is a better mech? I use a RDB Griff and Trident Carnage for range fighting. I've saved up about 9000 gold and could also but a Fury. I've been hording my gold for the upcoming Dash bots and Scourge. Bottom line is... Which is more worthwhile? Butch or Doc? And what setup? From what I can gather it seems that Ork/Tul for Doc and Trebuchet for Butch are really the only options. Thanks! I don't have a butch, but I play it sometimes on the test server. Best setup for it is probably quad trebs. So if you like sniping, and got a huge amount of silver then the butch is good for you. I hate sniping though... I play in D1/E3 iOS, and I have a doc mostly with Orkans on it. tulumbas also work. I personally tend to say the doc might be the best out of the three switchers, but I have the most fun with my aphid Jesse. Save your gold for the dashes tough, the fury can wait!
|
|
|
Post by WilsonK on Jun 22, 2017 2:34:12 GMT -5
I currently sit at low Diamond (3) or High Gold (1). I can buy with IP either 1 Butch or 2 Docs. Overall which is a better mech? I use a RDB Griff and Trident Carnage for range fighting. I've saved up about 9000 gold and could also but a Fury. I've been hording my gold for the upcoming Dash bots and Scourge. Bottom line is... Which is more worthwhile? Butch or Doc? And what setup? From what I can gather it seems that Ork/Tul for Doc and Trebuchet for Butch are really the only options. Thanks! I don't have a butch, but I play it sometimes on the test server. Best setup for it is probably quad trebs. So if you like sniping, and got a huge amount of silver then the butch is good for you. I hate sniping though... I play in D1/E3 iOS, and I have a doc mostly with Orkans on it. tulumbas also work. I personally tend to say the doc might be the best out of the three switchers, but I have the most fun with my aphid Jesse. Save your gold for the dashes tough, the fury can wait! Yes I personally agree with saving your gold for the new dash bots coming up. I've got Doc & Butch and a 「dookie」 ton of Jesse's from the last event. Personally fun to play with but not my style of play. Although I do give credit to Docs I've encountered in the battlefield, some wielding Tulumbas & Tarans, while coming out of cover and en-route to you, Tulus fires away, at 350m they switch to Tarans and throw plasma in your face, damn good. For Butch, huge ouch on maps like Yamantau, Springfield & Canyon
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Karma:
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 22, 2017 3:17:12 GMT -5
I currently sit at low Diamond (3) or High Gold (1). I can buy with IP either 1 Butch or 2 Docs. Overall which is a better mech? I use a RDB Griff and Trident Carnage for range fighting. I've saved up about 9000 gold and could also but a Fury. I've been hording my gold for the upcoming Dash bots and Scourge. Bottom line is... Which is more worthwhile? Butch or Doc? And what setup? From what I can gather it seems that Ork/Tul for Doc and Trebuchet for Butch are really the only options. Thanks! Depends on your play style. I personally hate sniping, can tolerate mid range fighting and love knife fighting. I've played all the WW bots and own 2 Docs and 2 Jessie's. I love my Aphid Jesse and have come to really appreciate my quad Tulu Doc. I tried orkans and orkan/tulu combo but Doc isn't really cut out for knife fighting imo. Gotta keep him outside 500m, move in, unload, move out. When I played the 8/8 Butch on the test server I saw what it was capable of but ultimately never felt comfortable piloting it. Of all the setups I felt quad trebs was the best though, Definitely save the gold to see what happens with the new bots. Good luck
|
|
|
Post by DarkVagabond on Jun 22, 2017 3:20:33 GMT -5
danmarinoI've had both since the anniversary event and I agree it's a tough choice between the two. I lean slightly more towards the Doc for my own purposes, mainly because I'm running the 4xTulu setup instead of an RDB Griffin. In general I hate running the same setups as everyone else - I always try to pick setups to counter the current meta. The Tulus reload time on the Doc just match so well with the Docs 15 second gunslinger recharge. You don't have to even watch your weapon reload. Just empty whatever Tulus you have left and know that you've got fully reloaded Tulus once you swap over. However, the Doc is REEEALLY squishy. It seems like a good idea to run it with 4 Orks, but you often don't even get to shoot the second pair before you die. The Ork Doc is best run in support of an Ancile teammate. In support you can do stupid damage numbers, if you're LUCKY. Still yet to try the Tulu/Ork setup. I reckon I've had enough practise with Tulu Doc now to give it a shot! I've tried various setups for my Butch, but I also keep coming back to 4xTrebs. It's just the smartest, as you can do a lot of unanswered damage. However, I t just takes forever to lvl up. I got my Trebs to lvl 5 before I swapped it out for another bot with more damage. Maybe you have more die hard patience than me. The only other possibility is really the Zeus/Trident combo. Start with Zeus and switch to Trident if they go around a corner or have a physical shield. However, you will do much more damage and last longer in the match with the mobility and Ancile of your Trident Carnage. This is not always a great thing. I have stayed in my Trident Carnage too long for many a match. At least with the midrange Butch dying sooner you don't stay in it too long, but that's not a compelling reason to use it over your Carnage. I even tried the Trident/Thunder setup for fun. God I wanted that setup to work.... the temptation to use it as a Thunder Carnage is too great. Think of a Thunder Carnage that is even slower, has no rush, no Ancile, and looks like Michael Jordan hiding behind a white picket fence. The word absurd comes to mind. So does fragbait. Even if you resist the temptation to use it as a knife fighter, by the time the enemy gets close enough to flank you (the only serious reason for equipping the Thunders), you're too beat up from midrange exchange to have any meaningful effect with the Thunders, and the reds take you down in short order. Maybe if I get the bot to lvl 12 I'll try to force it to work again... If you're really keen on a WW bot, may I ask, have you tried an Aphid Jesse? Think of an Aphid Patton that runs fast enough (max 64kph) to avoid other Aphid Pattons ANDt can cap beacons. It is also one of the shortest bots in the game and is safe behind a lot of low cover. In Expert League I'm all about scoring unanswered damage whenever I can, and the Aphid Jesse does this wonderfully from behind cover. Chubby Lancelots and RDB Griffins can't stand me! Definitely one of the most viable WW bot setups. But this is the pre dashbot era. Aphid users are gonna be hit hard by the dashbots... Don't know if that helps. I think save for dashbots, but otherwise Doc before Butch. And don't get two Docs. Save the rest and grind for Butch in the future while you're having fun with your Doc.
|
|
|
Post by ѻﻭɼﻉ on Jun 22, 2017 3:23:47 GMT -5
I am currently sitting in my hangar, drinking sake through advanced cybernetic hydration filter systems, and thinking about your question.
BUTCH
Butch is 「deteriorated bum-bum」! There are many useful set ups depending on what you want to focus on. Examples:
LR:
Quad LR weapons or a mix of two LR types. Quad trebuchet wins!
MIXED LR & MR:
2 treb/2 zeus 2 treb/2 trident - wins! 2 treb/2 thunder etc.
MR: 2 trident/2 zeus 2 trident/2 thunder 2 thunder/2 zeus etc
Hard call! I find thunder/zeus is the best when you want to be more mobile and get involved in closer combat. For MR less involved, Trident/Zeus is my favorite, and it looks frackin' awesome, which unfortunately is a downside because Butch is rare, and when you drop in, often several pilots will just sit there for the life of your mech just to watch lol
DOC
Doc is 「deteriorated bum-bum」! There are many useful set ups depending on what you want to focus on. Examples:
Tulumba/orkan: allows you to weaken with tulu then finish them off with orkans. This is good when pursuing or retreating from closer combat. Quad orkans is a really smooth set up, but requires closer range combat and so requires more skills to stay alive. Quad tulumbas is my favorite for max damage from a distance, which is good because Doc isn't good in a knife fight! This is by far my favorite. Hydras. I love using hydras, but not on Doc, so no comment. Quad molot mk2 is excellent for suppression and forcing mechs to hide or back up into the open. And, its super fun to send a continuous rain of gunfire at enemy mechs. Taran/orkan, wasn't into it. Punishers, no comment, I never use 'em.
Doc is faster and more nimble. Very useful for many reasons, especially because you can move locations quickly to help your team.
CHOOSING
Depends on what you want to do. If it were me I would get a Doc and a Jesse. Jesse is by far my favorite. If you don't want Jesse or already have, I would go with two Docs so I could have two load outs and not have to switch up. My load outs would be quad molot mk2, and quad tulumbas.
My experience is Doc is more useful to the team. Butch can come later.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Karma:
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 22, 2017 3:39:50 GMT -5
The Debbie downer news is that neither is great. Rdb Griff is better than tulu doc. And the longer range options you already run are fine. I would save ip and au as the Korean bots will not suck. Pix isn't playing around with them imo.
But if choose u must, go Butch. Treb Butch or trident+Zeus Butch at least does things no other bot does. Doc just doesn't do anything that Griff won't do better.
Cheers.
|
|
|
Post by Thunderkiss on Jun 24, 2017 15:33:01 GMT -5
You have it right.
Quad trebs and quad ork/tulumbas respectively.
No other setups come close.
|
|
|
Post by Team Alpha Strike on Jun 24, 2017 17:17:28 GMT -5
I'd forget the Treb Butch - too much silver to level up and it's performance is iffy the high the skilled pilots you face (cause stupidity gives down and field awareness goes up the higher the experience level if your opponent). The new Scourge will also hit Fury, Tasha, Leo, and Doc mid/long range setups the hardest. Please note - long range will absolutely suck after the Scourge gets here AND beacon rush mode gets here --- and since the Butch only works well with quad Trebs.......
The Doc get very interesting if that 15% increase in Orkan power gets passed through. If that goes through, just 2 level 11 can kill a Galahad outright. That means that the 2nd set of weapons can be anything you want them to be cause all you need is something that dishes out 40K damage and you've got a package that kills all non-Ancile bots below 160K. How about Okr/Scourge combo when the new weapons shows up? For now, you can pair up the Orks with Punishers, Molots, or Tulus - personally, I like Tulus with the Orks, but I have a set of Molots ready in case the Scourge makes battle under 600m a pain.
|
|
|
Post by Firebeard on Jun 24, 2017 17:27:09 GMT -5
Depending on the viability of the Dash-mecha, if I were to buy a Butch it would use Auto-cannon×2/Zues cannon×2 ..
Doc, for me works well with Orkan×2/Hydra×2 ..
|
|
|
Post by fιяєfℓαмє on Jun 25, 2017 6:09:46 GMT -5
If you have enought IP buy Wild Bunch bots(IMO if u like sniping buy Butch, but if u like brawling buy Doc), but if u don't have enought IP then save your golds untill dash bots comes.
|
|
|
Post by mijapi300 on Jun 25, 2017 15:16:19 GMT -5
The question of Butch or Doc is really a question between weapons. Butch is only effective with four Trebs, meaning you need to play it as a sniper. And it is an incredibly effective sniper, and may be even more valuable after Dashes arrive. The Doc is slightly more versatile, but really is only effective with Orkans or Tulumbas - I want one specifically for the latter. You'll have to take into account that they will likely nerf Tulumbas shortly after Dash arrives, so be prepared for that.
Both of these bots have very useful setups, even in the top tier - it just boils down to which type of gameplay you enjoy more.
Close range - Orkan Doc. Mid range - Tulu Doc. Long range - Treb Butch.
|
|
|
Post by drake1588 on Jun 25, 2017 16:42:59 GMT -5
I would wait a month or two and see what happens with the dash bots. It is plausible they will cost influence points. None of the wild west bots are life changing to the point of really bring worth their IP costs.
It's not that they are bad, it's just that they don't do anything that other bots don't do as well as they do. They do it differently, but in terms of overall effectiveness, they're basically the same.
Double ork doc has a lot of damage to offer, but really, he has the burst of a rogatka. A DB Griff does less damage over 8 seconds than a doc, but it does much more in the first 4 seconds, plus has jump in the toolbox. You often sustain less damage while still killing the target than a double work doc would because the doc can't fire all four at once.
Butch has similar firepower to a Fury, overall, but is far less versatile, rendering it only superior in a quad treb configuration.
Jesse is an outstanding aphid bot, but that is about it.
|
|